Old Acquaintance (Thursday, 7.12.07)
American Airlines Theatre, New York, NY
By: John van Druten (playwright), Michael Wilson (direction), Alexander Dodge (set design), David C. Woolard (costume design), Rui Rita (lighting design)
Starring: Margaret Colin (Katherine Markham), Corey Stoll (Rudd Kendall), Diane Davis (Deirdre Drake), Gordana Rashovich (Karina), Harriet Harris (Mildred Watson Drake), Cynthia Darlow (Susan), Stephen Bogardus (Preston Drake)
Two old female friends and rivals get together and the drama plays out between them. One could almost imagine such a play between two male rivals, although surely it would not be so caddy.
As much as I admire older shows, sitting through this production, I had a difficult time coming up with a compelling reason to revive this particular show. As a play, it is rather staid and uninteresting. The premise is flat, and development of the plot is predictable, and the characters are, even when developed, rather uninteresting. What the play does seem to provide, I will admit, is an opportunity for two actors to have lots of stage time, often with showy speeches and exchanges. It would appear to be a vehicle to showcase some good acting, which I suppose is part of the Roundabout formula for revivals. The real purpose here is to provide Margaret Colin and Harriet Harris with that opportunity to showcase their talents, via the plethora of comic moments and some emotionally showy exchanges.
Harris gets the better of the play in this regard, although this is at least in part because she has the showier part. She is a comic genius, really, and she does not disappoint, whether it is in her total breakdowns or in her playful banter. Margaret Colin is also good, but she has a more difficult task because her character is the “straight” one – although she has led an interesting life to be sure.
Even as a vehicle for stars, however, the piece tends to fall flat. Even though Katherine and Mildred seem to have time to go at it, in fact, the results of their banter are of little interest to anyone. I don't believe this is the fault of the actors, I believe it is the defect in the work itself.
From a design standpoint, this production also provides a tremendous opportunity for set design. It's rare, particularly in a play, that the scenery gets its own applause, but such is the case at the opening of the second act, when the curtain lifts to reveal a colorful, playful, and over-the-top home of the colorful and over-the-top Mildred. It is a spectacular set, to be sure, though part of me wonders whether the applause was simply a symptom of a desperate audience trying to find something to be happy about while watching this play.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment